Best Wet Cat Food According to Reddit

Should you buy wet or dry food for your pet? Well, this has been an age-old debate, and the truth is, there is no right or wrong answer to it. What you choose will fully depend on your feline friend. While many cat owners choose dry food, others prefer the wet type. One element that sets the wet food apart, particularly the canned one, is the moisture content. A high moisture content in cat food will keep your pet hydrated in all seasons. The good thing is, there are plenty of good brands out there, ranging from gluten-friendly to grain-less options, all easily digestible.

The best wet cat food is juicy and delicious, offering all the micronutrients, fats and proteins your pet needs to stay frisky and healthy. It should not contain too many additives, cheap fillers or carbohydrates. Most importantly, it should only be sourced from a reputable company and be accompanied by proper customer reviews. Here, we take a look at the most recommended food by Reddit users, with up-to-date information sourced from different subreddits.

Feline Natural

For many years, pet owners have relied on generic foods for their pets due to the lack of many options. Lately, there has been an increased urge to produce a large variety of cat food by manufacturers, with minimally processed natural foods getting the highest demand. Today, according to Amazon and Reddit reviewers, there could not be a better option than the Feline Natural brand.

Manufactured by the K9 Natural, this is the highest-rated brand on the market today. A Redditor, u/katinboots88 recommends this product, saying that Feline Natural is a top pick, and has been backed by other subreddits. If you are on the search for holistic, natural and safe food for your fluffy friend, this is the brand to look out for. Given that your carnivore pet needs a protein-rich diet, Feline Natural has been careful to include a high-quality amount of fish and meat to meet the required nutritional needs and ensure that your cat stays fit and strong.


  • Rich in minerals and vitamins
  • Natural ingredients
  • Nutritious and tasty
  • Excellent macronutrient profile
  • Grain, GMO and artificial ingredients-free


  • Not too widely exported
  • Expensive

Nature’s Variety Instinct Food

Nature’s Variety Instinct Wet Food is purely designed for cats with allergies. It is composed of proteins considered non-allergenic. At least 95 percent of this food is made of liver, rabbit, pork and broth. The extra 5 percent is composed of fiber and minerals, including ground flaxseed and montmorillonite clay, respectively, carrots and peas.

These boost the carbohydrate content of the food, although they do not offer much nutritional value. For many cats, pork and rabbit are lean proteins, which are excellent, particularly for those sensitive to other varieties such as beef and chicken. This food is also supplemented with omega 3 fatty acids in the form of fish oil, which reduces inflammation linked to allergies. A Redditor, shiplesp, agrees that this is among the best wet foods for cats today, and several others back this up.


  • Rich in animal proteins
  • Grain and GMO-free
  • Excellent for sensitive cats
  • Free of artificial flavors, colors and preservatives


  • Fairly expensive

Tiki Cat

Tiki Cat wet food is one of the most celebrated brands on the market today for its nourishing effects. This food is safe and free from animal by-products, potatoes and grains. The brand also excludes artificial additives, including preservatives, color and flavor. The recipe is composed of seafood flavor, real mackerel, high protein ingredients and multiple minerals, amino acids and vitamins.

Its carbohydrate content is very low, lower than that of fats, making this food the few carbohydrate-free diets for cats. Note; your cat does not need starch and carbohydrates. The only notable miss with this food is that it lacks some form of fiber that your furry friend needs for proper digestion. It means that feeding your cat on too much Tiki could get him constipated. If you are trying to avoid unnecessary plant ingredients or your cat is diabetic, suffers from UTI, IBS or CRF, Tiki Cat Makaha Grill, which is rich in moisture, could be a perfect choice. A Redditor, u/JPersnicket says Tiki Cat is among the best wet pet foods, only that it is expensive.


  • Highly nutritious
  • Rich in moisture
  • Grain-free
  • Real fish, real meat, real protein
  • Quality ingredients


  • Low in fiber
  • Some flavors have in chunks that many cats do not appreciate
  • Pricey

Pure Vita Canned Cat Food

Pure Vita wet food is rich in protein and loaded with real chicken. It contains proteinate minerals and vitamins, making it a perfect diet for your cat. Its top ingredients include chicken, natural flavor, chicken broth, calcium carbonate and liver. From amazon and Reddit reviews, this is a highly recommended choice. Chicken is the only protein source in this food.

If you need to manage your cat’s weight, this food could help because it is a high protein product and contains all the nutrients he needs. What’s more, this product is rich in added vitamins responsible for supporting a healthy immune system, including Vitamin E, A and D. An Amazon reviewer, Pascale, approves of this product, and has been supported by other reviewers.


  • High in protein
  • Valuable hydration
  • Grain-free
  • No fillers
  • Added vitamins and minerals
  • Super tasty


  • Expensive

Purina Pro Plan

Purina Pro Plan Focus Urinary Tract Health Adult Wet and Dry Food is designed to support your cat’s urinary tract. It is loaded with acidifiers with controlled dietary magnesium, elements that maintain a low urinary pH. This is a canned food product with chopped meat that consists of chicken, turkey, tomatoes, added flavors, colors and wheat gluten.

Note that if you are looking for alternatives to harmful additives, you will want to skip this product. Although it is high in carbohydrates and many artificial products, a lot of cats love it. Purina Pro has a moisture content of 78 percent, meaning that your cat stays hydrated throughout and urinates often to prevent crystals in the bladder. According to reviews from Reddit and Amazon, cat owners whose pets suffered from urinary issues benefited a lot from it. A subreddit, dorenello, recommends this food, with the support of several other reviewers.


  • Improves urinary tract issues
  • High moisture content
  • Real meat formulas for maximum protein
  • Rich in proteins
  • Many cats like it


  • High in carbohydrates
  • Artificial colors and flavors

Weruva Cats in the Kitchen Variety Pack Grain-Free Cat Food

Weruva is known to produce wet pet food, high in moisture content. The Weruva Cats in the Kitchen Variety Pack is meat-based with exceptional high proteins, starches and thickeners, carbohydrates and is low in fat. In the pack are fish loins, skinless and boneless white breast chicken, and lamb. It is a low-calorie food.

Given that the average amount of calories your cat should take daily is 200, you will need to feed your pet at least three pouches a day. On Amazon, this product has a 4.5 rating, with many reviewers recommending it for its vitamins, minerals and effectiveness. Margaret Auld-louie, an Amazon reviewer, approves of it with a 5-star rating, saying her cat loves it and appreciates the fact that it is highly digestible.


  • Does not contain plant protein fillers
  • No artificial ingredients
  • Rich in nutritious animal protein


  • High carbohydrate content
  • May be tough to scrape food off the pouch
  • Expensive

Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood Feast Canned Wet Cat Food

Fancy Feast Grilled Seafood offers complete nutrition loaded with vitamins and minerals, with no grain at all. This product offers kitties a yummy blend of seafood, one of the brands strongly loved by cats, according to many Amazon reviews. Each gravy serving contains grilles seafood feast, grilled salmon feast and grilled tuna feast.

Despite selling at a fairly high amount, this pack offers value for money, given its high nutrition content. Satisfy your kitty’s need for extraordinary protein-rich flavor with this cat food, whose meal features slow-cooked meat cuts. Jesse Danger, an Amazon reviewer, recommends this product, and many users agree with him.


  • Variety of seafood flavors
  • Multiple vitamins and proteins
  • Less than 1 percent carbohydrates
  • Well-balanced diet
  • Impressive moisture content


  • Expensive

Sheba Wet Cat Food

Sheba has a variety of signature broths, including fish, vegetables and meat, featured in a clear or a creamy broth, which many cats seem to love, according to many Reddit and Amazon reviews. The recipes range from Salmon, Tuna and Shrimp broths, vegetable and oceanfish in clear broth. These treats do not contain plant protein, are grain-free and have no starches.

Although fish is delicious, it is not the best source of protein for cats, so you may want to choose the meaty variety such as Sheba Perfect Portions Grain-Free Tender Beef Entrée Cat Food. This variety is made of beef in beef broth, beef liver, chicken liver and chicken. The food has amino acids, synthetic vitamins and omega-3 supplementation from fish oil. A subreddit recommends this product, and many others on the r/Frugal platform approve of it.


  • Not loaded with plant protein fillers
  • Contains fish oil for omega-3
  • Rich in nourishing animal protein
  • Low in carbohydrates


  • Contains added color
  • Poultry by-products

Nulo Wet Cat Food

Nulo offers three different types of cat products, with Nulo Adult & Kitten Grain-Free Canned Wet Cat Food being the only wet variety. This canned food will give your cat top quality in terms of real meat. It does not have any meal or poultry by-products because the meat is sourced from the muscles and organs, both of which contain a high nutritional value. If you have kittens, this will be the best option given that they will need the rich nutrition for healthy development.

This food comes in a thick formulation, which means that it is not loaded with unnecessary carbohydrates. The recipe is enriched with vitamins and minerals drawn from dried kelp, fish oil, pumpkin and cranberries. Cat owners whose pets have suffered from allergies from other foods say that this variety has been excellent for their pets because it is grain-free. Nostaljack, a Reddit reviewer, says Nulo produces some of the best cat foods and highly recommends.


  • High-quality proteins
  • Enriched with essential nutrients and vitamins
  • No grain
  • Low carb
  • Promotes weight management
  • Reduces food sensitive allergies
  • High water content


  • Considered expensive by many buyers
  • Some cats reject the taste

When selecting the best wet cat food, it is important that you do so with informed choices to ensure you are getting what’s right for your feline. Some of the features you need to keep in mind when making your purchase include the brand reputation, flavor, nutritional value, the cat it is designed for and portion size.

Leave a Comment